The “Anti-Hero” artist looked glamorous and chic donning a floral midi dress with spaghetti straps, black heels, and a black waist belt as she hit up New York City’s Via Carota.

One Swift fan account posted video on X of her walking right past people seated outside who were clearly stunned to see the pop icon. The clip showed a woman whose mouth dropped when she saw Swift and captioned it: “That face when you’re having dinner & Taylor Swift shows up.”

Other Swifties responded to the video writing, “This girl’s reaction represents the entire fandom right now” and “She just spoke what the entire fandom feels without a word!”